New York Pizzeria

The Baios have been blessed to share their family and their lives with the people they have served since 1982

We opened on January 13, 1982. We have been so blessed to share our lives and families with all of you. Thanks!

We offer Commerce Chenango Member-to Member Discounts.

One of the many wonderful Things you will Be able to purchase @ The New Berlin Farmers Market - Coming Soon

Lunch Specials for Wednesday May 10, 2017

Packed full of goodness - Homemade Lentil Soup

Sweet Chili Chicken Salad

Ham & Swiss Panini with Honey Mustard, side of fries

We Love to Serve You

Pathfinder Village (Community for Down syndrome)

We love Pathfinder Village (Community for Down syndrome) and are humbled to be recognized by them.

SPLASH PATH SPONSOR SPOTLIGHT: Today, everyone at Pathfinder Village gives a big "shout out" to the Baio Family and the tremendous folks New York Pizzeria in New Berlin, New York. If you're looking for looking for great Italian-American fare, or delicious specialties to enjoy at home with your family and friends, NYP is the place to go! Learn more at

Pathfinder's relationship with NYP began soon after Frank Baio opened his restaurant in the former tv repair shop back in 1982. As Frank and Betsey's business grew, they embraced the local community and were always ready to help out with school events, local fund raisers, and many other community benefit events. Today that commitment continues, and after 35 years, if you talk about the Village of New Berlin, New York Pizzeria (or "Frankie's" as many locals call it) invariably comes up as one of the best eateries in the region and as a local landmark.

Frank and Betsey, and now their children's families, all have a soft spot for the families of Pathfinder Village. Each year, son Rosario hosts our "Master Chef Pizza Contests" during our Leadership Week for Otsego Academy, and the Baios have offered pizza-maker training to members of our Adult Day Services program.

Thanks again, for your sponsorship of Splash Path, and for all that you provide to the area and to Pathfinder Village. GRAZIE!

So proud of the students that performed Annie Jr as part of the UVCS drama club - especially Shawn, Isabel, Mike & Kyleigh, who are part of our NYP family 💕

We love families and we love birthday's - thanks for partying with us - Happy 70th Lyle

Salmon is on - come and get it 😊

Videos (show all)



General Manager




Catering Groups Kids Reserve Takeout Waiter Walkins


Dinner Lunch

Price Range


Payment Options

Amex Discover Mastercard Visa



7 S Main St
New Berlin, NY

Opening Hours

Monday 10:30am - 9:30pm
Tuesday 10:30am - 9:30pm
Wednesday 10:30am - 9:30pm
Thursday 10:30am - 10pm
Friday 10:30am - 10pm
Saturday 10:30am - 10pm
Sunday 10:30am - 9:30pm
Other New Berlin restaurants (show all)
Remember When Cafe, Antiques & Guest House Remember When Cafe, Antiques & Guest House
34 N Main St
New Berlin, 13411

Great cafe with healthy meal salads, juicy burgers, fresh and grilled sandwiches and a very health conscious salmon meal. Comfortable, private guest rooms

T's Diner, L.L.C T's Diner, L.L.C
5079 State Highway 8
New Berlin, 13411

Friendly service and great homemade food!

Butternut Valley Golf Butternut Valley Golf
435 Elliott Rd
New Berlin, 13411

We are the whole in one! Golf course is open Wednesday- Sunday from 9AM to dusk. Kitchen is open from noon to close Wednesday-Sunday's.

Deerpath Restaurant Deerpath Restaurant
Route 8
New Berlin, 13411

Great food for great people. If you don't see it on the menu just ask! All food is made to order and fresh.

Lloyd's B-B-Q Lloyd's B-B-Q
5110 State Highway 80
New Berlin, 13411

B-B-Q concession stand on the corner! Look for the pig!!!